Defending the faith...
The questions almost always cover the same old worn out issues...gays, priests marrying, abortion, contraception, yadda, yadda, yadda.
The questions almost always come from fallen away Catholics who are battling some authority...Mom and Dad, Pope, parish priest, nun, yadda, yadda, yadda.
And almost always the questions have been formed by the popular media. Or by the memories of childhood catechism classes and not with the rational (and by that I am not meaning to sound as if the questioner is therefore irrational) facilities of an adult.
This requires the seeking of answers by searching them out in Church literature (catechism, encyclicals, etc., etc.) and NOT by reading the editors of the NY and LA Times or the literature of those who dissent with the Church and who therefore DON'T clear up, or satisfactorily give an answer to honest questions.
So it is almost always, without exception and eye opener for the inquisitor when someone can at least give them something of an answer without seemingly being defensive or dismissive.
Today's question had to do with the dinosaur the Church had become and that it ought to enter the 21st century by sloughing off the detritus of the ages, or it will die.
Yeah, it sounds more like a statement than a question but I took it as a question and tried to give the inquisitor a starting off point for actually seeking out an answer from sources more reliable than myself...
So for this one I like to start off with the notion of the burden of the past. The Church, I normally state, moves ponderously because it has to poll the past not only to answer questions for the here and now, but to also better guide the future.
I point to the social writings of Leo XIII and Paul VI to give some examples of how the Church spoke to the culture, warning us about the headlong rush into some uncharted territory just for the sake of being progressive, without taking into account how the past, how previous cultures, or societies looked at the issues at stake.
I'm not looking to convince...just to open the door a bit to the idea that some of their ideas about the Church might be faulty.
Then I like to point out that Western culture doesn't have this sense of the past. I use an analogy from essayist Richard Rodriguez who was speaking specifically about American culture, but it also applies to the West.
Our culture, wrote Mr. Rodriguez, is a lot like the table at an all night diner. Families come and, for a time, live and play at the table. They laugh and love, make huge messes and then are gone.
Then the waitress comes along and wipes away all traces of those who just left, just in time for another group to come in and do it all over again.
Now often times this is where the inquisitor looks thoughtfully and says something along the lines of "hmmm..I hadn't quite seen it in that light before..."
Which is all I ask for.
Again, I'm not looking to convince, I'm hoping that they seek beyond me and find the truth.
